My First AI Interview: Cool, Weird, and Totally Impersonal

So today I had my first AI interview. Honestly, I was hesitant at first…but I decided to go through with it. And whew… what an experience. It was weird, a little cool from a tech perspective, but overall so impersonal.

The flow of the experience was fine. I was greeted by a friendly enough AI bot named “Alex,” who asked a series of pre-written questions. I responded to each with my verbal and on-screen responses, trying to show my personality through a screen… to a robot.

But let me tell you…this cannot be the future of interviewing. There was no real-time engagement, no ability to ask clarifying questions or feel out the vibe of the person “on the other side.” It felt like trying to spark a conversation with a voicemail.

Here’s the thing: If I can’t bring in an AI advocate to represent me as a candidate (which would be absurd), why are companies outsourcing something as human and nuanced as an interview to a chatbot? I get it…efficiency, scalability, streamlining. But also? Yikes.

Of course, a few hours later, I received that dreaded “thanks, but no thanks” email. One of those auto-generated rejection notes we’ve all gotten a dozen times. No feedback, no real context, just a vague brush-off. You know the spiel. I honestly feel like it was a ploy to sign up for this AI assistant because after my interview they sent a marketing email.

Simon Sinek once said, “If you don’t understand people, you don’t understand business.” That quote played in my head the moment I got the AI interview request. And it rang even louder after going through the process.

So what did I take away from all this?

  • Technology is amazing, but it shouldn’t replace human connection.
  • I want to work with teams who see people, not just profiles.
  • I’m proud of myself for showing up, even when it felt uncomfortable and uncertain.
  • Every “no” brings me closer to the right “yes.”

Maybe the future of interviews includes more AI…but I still believe the best work (and the best hiring decisions) happen when real people connect.

So to anyone else navigating this strange job market: keep going. Keep being human. The right team will appreciate what you bring to the table and they’ll want to hear it straight from you, not your recording.

One response to “My First AI Interview: Cool, Weird, and Totally Impersonal”

  1. Write In Mind Avatar

    This really resonated with me, especially the part about how impersonal the experience felt and not being able to engage in real time. That voicemail comparison honestly sums it up perfectly. AI can be useful for structure and prep, but interviews still need that human connection. I’ve noticed that balance matters a lot when practicing with tools like LockedIn AI—AI should support candidates, not replace the human side of hiring. Thanks for sharing such an honest experience.

    Like

Leave a Reply

About Me
Ameera

Hello, I’m Ameera—the creative force and beating heart behind this blog. A dedicated cappuccino enthusiast with a flair for leadership and digital marketing, I’ve embarked on a mission to unravel the hidden gems of the coffee scene in Chicagoland. My passion lies in injecting a fresh perspective into the realms of marketing and leadership—peeling away the unnecessary layers to discover joy in life’s simple pleasures.

Discover more from First, Coffee. Then, Go Forth & Inspire!

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading